On Democracy, Corruption, And Tyranny Essay - 833 Words

Section 2: On Democracy, Corruption, and Tyranny Consider, for example, Pericles’ assertion that law is â€Å"all things†¦that the assembled multitude has approved and written, pointing out what should and should not be done† (1.2.42). Alcibiades’ then asks Pericles â€Å"what if it is not the multitude, but the resembled few who write [the law]? What is this this?† (1.2.43); Pericles concedes that is too can be considered as law (1.2.43). Alcibiades then asks â€Å"what [then becomes of] violence and lawlessness? Is it not when one who is stronger compels one who is weaker not by persuasion but by the use of violence?† (1.2.44). Pericles revises his initial position by stating that â€Å"everything†¦that one compels someone to do without persuading him†¦is violence rather than law† (1.2.45). Alcibiades, inspired by Pericles’ revision, then asks him if â€Å"whatever the whole multitude writes†¦when it overpowers those having wealth, would be violence rather than law?† (1.2.45). Pericles completely dodges the question, applauds Alcibiades’ youth and cleverness, and makes a remark about how he himself was once like Alcibiades (1.2.46). Finally, Alcibiades states â€Å"†¦I could have been your companion at the time, Pericles, when you where at your cleverest† (1.2.46). At stake here, is the extent to which the subversive nature of Socrates’ anti-democratic pedagogical praxis can be directly held responsible for having corrupted Alcibiades. Indeed, we learn earlier on in the Memorabilia, that part of the logicShow MoreRelatedImpact of John Stuart Mill’s Philosophies on Philippines’ Society, Politics and Economy1093 Words   |  5 PagesPhilippines’ Society, Politics and Economy Mendoza, A.; SocSci 2 WBYDX John Stuart Mill’s social, political, and economic philosophies are widely applied in the Philippine setting. His conception of social liberty, feminism, political democracy and economic democracy is practiced in the country, although not holistically applied or not well-carried out at some cases. Philippines, as a democratic country, adapts the libertarian culture that Mill believes to be the best for achieving intellectualRead MoreEssay on Platos Republic981 Words   |  4 Pagesperfect society. He outlines a utopian society, out of his disapproval for the tension of political life. Plato lived through the Peloponnesian War (431-404 BC), in which much of Greece was devastated. This created poverty and political confusion and corruption. Therefore, Plato created a sketch of a society in which the problems he thought were present would be eased. Essentially, The Republic deals with the question of justice and therefore with the questions what is a just state? and who is aRead MoreAristotles Endorsement of Polity as the Best Possible for Most States746 Words   |  3 Pagesbest understand the whole society, and would therefore be good to rule; that the poor should perform deliberative and judicial functions but not allowed to hold office. In terms of types of ‘polity’ this is a mixture of oligarchy and democracy. Aristotle believes that the best possible state, one in which virtue is best able to prevail is one in which some political functions are assigned to the many poor and lower classes, and other functions to the few rich and well bornRead MoreTyranny And The Social Wellbeing Of Citizens1750 Words   |  7 Pagesconcerned themselves at some point with the issue of tyranny in society. Such writers spanned from Alexis de Tocqueville, to John Stuart Mill, to Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. The interpretations and approaches taken to the subject of tyranny and how to protect against it, though, were as varied as the collection of authors who addressed it. From de Tocqueville’s stringent observations in Democracy in America, the concept of a purely political tyranny is delineated. In contrast, Mill’s essay On LibertyRead MoreAristotle s Views On The Morality Of Government1350 Words   |  6 Pagesespecially something the ancient Greek philosophers argued over as they were ruled by a patriarchal democracy. Plato and later Aristotle grappled with this question over who should rule and what various forms or kinds of rule would look like. Aristotle mentions a few various true fo rms of government such as a kingship, aristocracy, and polity as well as their perverted forms such a tyranny, oligarchy, and democracy. The perverted forms are the same as the true ones only the true forms rule for the commonRead MoreDifference Between a Democracy and a Republic Essay652 Words   |  3 Pages There is a fundamental difference between a democracy and a republic as it concerned the political entitlement of the citizenry. The citizens of a republic do not participate directly with governmental affairs. The citizens of a republic can however have a say in who does participate. The Roman republic has two prefect systems to prevent dictatorship which didn’t work. The Romans called their political system not democracy but republic. Republic is something that belongs to the people. In Rome theRead MoreDoes Democracy Ensure Freedom?1057 Words   |  5 PagesDoes democracy ensure freedom? I believe democracy can ensure freedom, but not always, thus my answer is maybe. For democracy is a form of government that rely on a system of law in which individuals are treated equally while having fair access to the legislative process through electing official who will act in their constituent’s interest and voice their concern. Through proper protection with legislation, individuals freedom can be ensured. Yet the nature of democracy favour majority thus itRead MorePopulist Leadership, Modern Tyranny1421 Words   |  6 PagesPopulist Leadership, Modern Tyranny Introduction: In the paper presented below, the author assembles an idea about populism as a modern tyranny, taking book IX as a reference for the similarity of certain features among a populist leader today, with the tyrant of yesterday described by Plato. According to Socrates the democratic man arose from the oligarchic father when he dared to place in the same rank the necessary and unnecessary desires enjoying them in moderation. In Book IX of the treatiseRead MoreHenrik Ibsens Expression of Beliefs in An Enemy of the People1715 Words   |  7 Pageswriting it is easy to skim over the in depth back round. Looking deeper, one can find a multi-layered plot with many social and political messages between the lines. Ibsen had a problem with particular parts of government, such as, tyranny of the majority, Parliamentary democracy, and the hypocrisy of the liberal press. An Enemy of the People is a realistic stage drama in five acts. It depicts ordinary life, as it is, not as a fantasy unlike oth er common literature. An Enemy of the People, by Henrik IbsenRead MoreJohn Stuart Mill Essay1369 Words   |  6 PagesJohn Stuart Mill, there is a concern for the tyranny of the majority. He expresses his concern in, On Liberty, by supporting an increase in individual liberties. It is expressed again in, On Representative Government, by promoting a true democracy. Mill proposes remedies for combating this tyranny of the majority, and further discusses the compatibility of those remedies and the effect they will have on society. Mill addresses the `tyranny of the majority as the absolute power being vested